Both cars have been highly acclaimed in the global market and established fair bit of reputation this year. But reading others' review is quite different from driving the cars your own, so here is a bit of my view on both.
Honda CR-V VTi 2.4 4WD
Pros:- It's a clear winner if look and feel is the only criteria. The smooth curves make it quite attractive looking. My other half got instantaneously captivated.
- The interiors also wins at quite a margin. The materials Honda use looks good. The backseat leg room is spacious, the storage space is quite generous too.
- Driving on city roads, the engine is dead quiet and smooth.
- The steering wheel feels a bit too agile and sensitive to my taste.
- At sharp corner turns, the CRV is not as stable as Forester, which gave me a sort of uncertain feeling at the turning speed and a hint of unsafety. I'm not sure if its center of gravity is higher, or its automatic switching between 2WD to 4WD was not intelligent enough to detect all scenarios.
- On motorway driving pass 90KM/H, the CRV's accelerator clearly felt soft and powerless. Especially when you carry a few passengers and the road is a bit uphill, the engine just didn't react much on your acceleration.
- Lastly, personally opinion, I don't like foot pedal brake.
Subaru Forester 2.5i AWD
Pros:- Its power never failed me, no matter on a steep slope or on motor way, the acceleration was as much as I wanted it to be.
- I felt almost 100 percent control on road conditions, and I knew exactly how hard I need to step on the accelerator. This feeling is quite important.
- The exterior look is definitely a step up from its previous generations.
- Engine is noisier, especially at starts.
- The interior is so humdrum. The materials and accessories are very basic, and the dashboard & stereos look so old-styled.
- Driver's left side legroom is quite limited.
- Open the bonnet, the giant ugly plastic intake manifold is quite an eye-catcher. I did some research afterwards and found the benefits of plastic intake manifolds are actually outweigh the aluminum design. However it gave me a rather cheap feeling.
No wonder some people say a Subaru is "drivers' car". As driver, I do prefer the feeling of driving the new Forester, it gives me the confidence of total control, which I'm pretty sure affects safety too. So I can compromise on its look and feel.
CRV is a good car too. However it just gives me a touch feeling of uncertainty. I know there are plenty of expert reviews bragging on the enhanced safety, fuel efficiency and utility of CRV, and also cons of the Forester's less fuel efficiency and its noisy engine. But I'm pretty much decided go for Subaru. Now just wait for their financial year sale.